The report that dared to admit failure

This bold move - voluntarily sharing the messy, difficult truth - is why the report went viral among experts and became a model for how corporations should talk about their impact. The company’s founder, Yvon Chouinard, set the tone by saying the company is “not perfect by any means,” but that the "fear of getting things wrong in the process cannot stop us from trying to get things right in the end”.

The biggest shock was the data: Patagonia’s long-term goal is to reach net-zero emissions by 2040, which requires cutting pollution by 10% every year. Yet, the report openly revealed that in the last year (Fiscal Year 2025), the company’s total carbon pollution actually rose by 2%.

Instead of trying to hide this bad news, Patagonia explained exactly why it happened. This level of honesty transformed a setback into a powerful lesson in accountability.

‍

The freedom to be honest: Earth is the only shareholder

Why could Patagonia share bad news without fearing a backlash from investors? The answer lies in its unique ownership structure, which protects its mission from short-term financial pressure.

A few years ago, the founder transferred ownership of the company to two entities: one that holds the voting power and another that receives all the extra profit.

• Profit for the planet: This structure ensures that any money the company earns, after reinvesting in the business, goes directly to an environmental non-profit dedicated to fighting the climate crisis.
• Mission protected: This means the company's core mission - to save the home planet - is legally more important than making maximum profit for outside shareholders.

Because "Earth is the only shareholder", the company doesn't have to worry about investors getting angry over short-term costs, such as funding expensive factory cleanups or admitting a rise in pollution. This freedom from traditional Wall Street pressures allows for radical honesty in a way few other companies can achieve.

‍

Admitting the problem: The backpack dilemma

The report’s credibility rests on its willingness to share the why behind its 2% pollution increase:

1. The source of the problem: Patagonia confirmed that 92% of its carbon footprint comes from its supply chain - meaning the raw materials (like fabric) and the factories that make the finished goods.
2. The change in products: The increase happened because the company shifted its product focus in FY2025, selling more backpacks, duffels, and heavier gear. These products require "more carbon-intensive" materials compared to lighter clothing.

‍

This explanation was hailed by experts because it showed the company has precise control over its data and understands the exact link between the products it sells and the pollution it causes. It demonstrates that Patagonia is truly measuring the hard things, not just the easy ones.

‍

The "no shortcuts" strategy

Patagonia refuses to engage in "greenwashing," where a company appears eco-friendly without making fundamental changes. The report highlighted several commitments that demonstrate this resolve:

• No more green claims: Patagonia opens its report with the uncompromising statement, “Nothing we do is sustainable,” acknowledging that making new products always has an environmental cost.
• The no-offset rule: The company maintains a strict "no carbon offset" policy, meaning it refuses to pay another party to clean up emissions elsewhere to pretend it is "carbon neutral". Instead, all its effort and money must be focused on cleaning up its own factories and supply chain.
• The coal mandate: To tackle the massive supply chain pollution problem, Patagonia is using its purchasing power to enforce change. In 2024, it implemented a mandatory policy forcing all suppliers to develop a specific, scheduled plan to stop using coal.
• The internal investment fund: Moving beyond simply asking suppliers to change, the company created an innovative financial tool called the Verified Carbon Intervention Unit (VCIU). This functions as an internal fee - totaling $37.3 million in FY2025 - which is used to fund major, expensive structural changes at partner factories, like helping them switch to clean energy.

‍

Honesty on social goals and materials

The report also brought the same level of honesty to social issues, particularly worker welfare.

• The Living Wage Gap: Patagonia has an internal goal to ensure all its apparel factory workers earn a living wage - enough money to meet basic needs - by 2025. The report honestly shared that, as of 2022 data, only 34% of its apparel assembly factories were paying a living wage on average. By sharing this lagging and difficult data, the company shows that closing global wage gaps is a complex, industry-wide challenge that requires partnership, not just promises.‍
• Cleaning up chemicals: On a more positive note, the company confirmed that from its Spring 2025 line onward, 100% of all new styles are made without intentionally added PFAS (the "forever chemicals" that are toxic and polluting).

‍

Lessons for any business: The new blueprint for trust

The professional community embraced Patagonia's report because it set a new, higher standard for business transparency. Here are the most valuable lessons other companies can learn from this article:

‍

1. Change your structure

If possible, legally tie your company's mission to its purpose so environmental goals cannot be easily sacrificed for quick profits. This gives you the freedom to be truly honest.

‍

2. Confess your failures

Don't hide bad news. When you miss a goal (like rising pollution), explain the failure with specific data (like the shift to more carbon-intensive backpacks) and outline the steps you are taking to fix it.

‍

3. Pay to fix the problem

Don't just demand that your supply chain partners clean up. Create internal funds (like the $37.3 million VCIU) to help pay for the difficult and expensive changes they need to make to switch away from dirty energy like coal.

‍

4. Prioritize durability

Make products that last a long time and commit to fixing them. Patagonia repaired 174,799 products in one year, which keeps items out of the landfill and reduces the need for new materials.

‍

5. Stay humble

Acknowledge that the work is never finished. By labeling the report a "Work in Progress", the company invites conversation and partnership rather than declaring victory, which ultimately builds deeper trust.

‍

The ultimate takeaway is that in the modern economy, true corporate leadership is demonstrated not by perfect results, but by the willingness to be vulnerable, imperfect, and fully committed to the difficult, ongoing work of systemic change. The commitment to show their ongoing "experiment" in business - including the failures - is the reason their report is now considered the new gold standard.

‍

Discover Patagonia's 2025 Impact Report here